Re: [Full-disclosure] HTTP AUTH BASIC monowall.

[Tim <tim-security@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

> Actually, encryption can do some good, even in the absence of authentication.
> 
> Even if the remote end is totally unauthenticated, you have at least 
> guaranteed
> that nobody is doing any passive sniffing of the content in transit.  You've
> at least forced an attacker to mount an active MitM attack, which is both more
> challenging and has a higher risk of detection....

I concede.  In the vast majority of communications situations, MitM is
only a little more difficult than passive sniffing, but in some it does
make a difference.  In particular, some broadcast mediums make MitM very
difficult without detection (radio broadcast, for instance).

In addition, if you can guarantee perfect forward secrecy without
authentication, at least the attacker must use a MitM attack right then.
Offline analysis won't reveal the encrypted content.

thanks,
tim.

_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/